Hippocrates and the oath nobody swears any more

Imagine a 62-year-old physician from Kos coming to visit today. Beard, sandals, a papyrus roll under his arm. You tell him that every doctor on this planet still swears his oath. He would have to sit down.

And that would be, scientifically speaking, a small white lie.

Because the Hippocratic Oath — that solemn text which supposedly every medical student holds aloft at the end of their studies like a scout taking a promise — is today practically nowhere sworn in its ancient form. What is sworn (and even that is not binding everywhere) is the Declaration of Geneva. It was formulated in 1948 by the World Medical Association, revised several times, most recently in 2017. It carries Hippocrates’ name roughly the way a restaurant is called “Mama’s”: out of piety and marketing.

The original version would have given a modern medical association a certain amount of trouble.

There is, first of all, the opening formula: “I swear by Apollo the physician, by Asclepius, by Hygieia and Panacea.” Four gods, right in the first lines. In the plenary of the 1948 Geneva assembly that would, to put it cautiously, not have commanded a majority.

Then the famous surgical prohibition: “I will not cut, not even for bladder stones.” Hippocrates regarded surgery as something to be left to specialists — a position today’s surgeons would struggle to live with.

Next comes the economically most delicate clause: the physician undertakes to support his teacher as he would a father. And to teach the teacher’s sons without a fee. You can imagine how that idea would go down in a world with pay scales and medical association statistics.

And then there is that one sentence everyone thinks they know: Primum non nocere. First, do no harm.

It is not in the oath.

It is not, in fact, in the surviving writings of Hippocrates at all — at least not like that. What is really there is found in the “Epidemics”, and it sounds distinctly more pragmatic: to help, or at least to do no harm. Somewhere between Galen and the Renaissance, this sober clinician’s motto turned into a Latin bon mot that prints better on fridge magnets.

What is left once you subtract the gods, the surgical prohibition, the hereditary succession and the most famous quotation in medical history — that is the Declaration of Geneva. It has one core sentence, and it means it seriously: The health and well-being of my patient will be my first consideration.

That is, if you look closely, the same thing in a new form: the very reason Hippocrates wrote the whole text back then. Putting the patient first. Not out of piety, but out of professional ethics.

In that sense our guest from Kos has every reason to sit down again — this time out of relief. His favourite idea has survived 2,400 years. It is just more concisely phrased now, less laden with gods, and comes expressly from Geneva.

What remains is a nice example of how tradition works. You keep the name. You keep the idea. You throw the rest away. And everyone goes on nodding reverently.

Perhaps that is the most instructive thing about the story anyway. Not every winged medical phrase comes from the person it is attributed to. Not every solemn oath is actually sworn. And not every tradition is as old as it pretends to be.

But the core idea — patient first — is considerably older than Geneva.

And considerably more current than Apollo.

Fancy stories like this as short videos? Come with us and Mia from pharmapunk into the past on TikTok and on Instagram. We visit historical figures at the moment of their discoveries.